Total Pageviews

Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Some gems from Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy

In Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy, Irving Tomlinson shares many quotes from Mary Baker Eddy, Discoverer and Founder of Christian Science.

 

Here is a quote (page 87) that I have not found anywhere else:

“One time she told us not to say there is too much or too little of anything. She said: God governs. He knows best. He will do all things right.”

 

And page 95 tells us that, “She once contrasted sympathy and compassion by referring to the feeding of the multitude by Jesus, by saying that Jesus had compassion and fed them; he sympathized with them, he would have suffered because of their hunger.”

 

Same page: “When we are talking to one who is not a Christian Scientist, in speaking of a disease, she continued, we are not to say that So-and-so has a belief. Say plainly that he is sick. And she quoted Paul’s admonition, ‘I had rather speak five words with my understanding. . .than ten thousand words in an unknown tongue.’”

 

Page 98: “Error comes to you for life, and you give it all the life it has.”

 

Page 106, 1st para.: “Each day there should drop from your lips some manna to heal and bless others.”

 

And “Desire is prayer. Words without desire are not prayer.”

 

Page 109: “I have striven earnestly to have my students speak in a language which would be understood,” Mrs. Eddy said. “It is not right for one to say to a poor sufferer, wracked with pain, ‘Nothing ails you. You have no pain. You are not suffering.’ I have said to students making this mistake, ‘The next time you visit a patient tie a string to your tongue.’”

 

Page 156: “At supper one evening she commented, ‘I do not believe in too much organization in church. The churches are over-organized. Were I to have charge of a church today, I should have it founded on the Bible. I should talk to them from the Bible. I should direct their thought to the Bible, and I should expect them to be obedient to the Bible.’”

Joyce Voysey

Monday, 30 March 2026

Mrs. Eddy and the clergy

The Longyear Museum website has a helpful biography of the author of our book Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy. Here is a portion: 


IRVING C. TOMLINSON ...earned his Bachelor and Master’s degrees from Akron University in Akron, Ohio, in 1884, and his Bachelor of Divinity degree from Tufts University in Boston in 1888. After an earnest study of Christian Science, which included Primary class with Mrs. Eddy’s student Flavia Knapp, Irving gave up the pulpit, joined The Mother Church in 1897, and became a Journal-listed practitioner. 

In 1898, he was invited by Mrs. Eddy to attend her last class, and he served intermittently on the Bible Lesson Committee until 1927. 

...From 1899 until 1910, Rev. Tomlinson served Mrs. Eddy in various ways, including as an associate secretary and a member of her Chestnut Hill household.


In his book  Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy, the former clergyman, Tomlinson, writes that

Mrs. Eddy taught a number of clergymen who had become interested in her teachings. She was always happy to have ministers of the Gospel as her students. Nor as a rule would she accept any tuition fee from them for instruction in the Massachusetts Metaphysical College; and if two persons made application with one of them a minister, and only one could be admitted, the clergyman was usually the one favored. 

There were however some clergymen during those years who were bitterly denouncing Christian Science and its Discoverer." See p. 82. 

Tomlinson offers a lovely story about “Mrs. Eddy’s friendly attitude toward the clergy" on page 83.

Julie Swannell

Thursday, 12 March 2026

Two parts to the discovery of Christian Science

On page 43 of Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy (Amplified Edition), author Irving Tomlinson tells us that Mrs. Eddy made the following remark at the time of the “Next Friends” law suit:*

I said to the masters that the discovery that the unmedicated pellet produced the same effect as the medicated pellet was the falling apple which led to the discovery of Christian Science. This must be taken with another fact. I have said that my recovery from a fall in Lynn when I opened the Bible and read there of the healing dated the discovery of Christian Science. The first was the enlightenment of the human understanding, the second was the revelation from the divine Mind.

Ah! I can see that point, as it can occur in comparatively minor ways in our own lives, particularly as students of Christian Science.

For some reason I am reminded of an article I found on JSH-Online by our author Rev. Irving Tomlinson, entitled Only a Belief (Christian Science Sentinel Oct 20, 1898). It tells of the loss of two gold teeth which turned out to be not lost. I hope readers may be able to find it for themselves (Ed. or ask a Reading Room librarian to source it for you).

* For “Next Friends suit” see Mary Baker Eddy: Years of Authority by Robert Peel (available in Christian Science Reading Rooms).

Joyce Voysey

Wednesday, 11 March 2026

"Canst thou not minister to a mind diseas'd"

In our March book Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy (Expanded edition) by Rev. Irving C. Tomlinson, MA, CSB, I was interested to read about Mary Baker Eddy and Shakespeare. I knew she was familiar with Shakespeare's work.

 

Doesn’t Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures (written by Mary Baker Eddy) have a Shakespearean quote (from Hamlet) on page iii, set between a quote from John’s gospel and a poem by the author?

There is nothing either good or bad,

but thinking makes it so.

 

Tomlinson tells us that she was able to quote from Macbeth Act 5, scene 3. He writes (page 17):  Mrs. Eddy addressed us by repeating the following from Macbeth act V, scene 3 –

Canst thou not minister to a mind diseas’d,

Pluck from the memory a rooted sorrow,

Raze out the written troubles of the brain,

And with some sweet oblivious antidote

Cleanse the stuff’d bosom of that perilous stuff

Which weighs upon the heart?

 

He goes on,

These lines were repeated without hesitation, and with the accent and intonation which indicated a familiarity that might be expected of a noted actor. I asked two longtime workers in Mrs. Eddy’s household if they remembered it as a quotation often used by Mrs. Eddy. Both said that they had never heard her use the lines before.

 

One can certainly understand why those lines were so meaningful to Mrs. Eddy.

 

On page 30 we find a passage which tells us of Mrs. Eddy’s handling of an unruly child in the school she started in Tilton for children 8 to 10 years. (This would have been before she discovered the Christ Science.)

 

I shall copy it here.

A mother whose ten-year-old son was so ungovernable that she had sent him to the reform school came to me and begged that I take her boy into my school. I hesitated but at last yielded to her entreaties. The first day the boy behaved very badly. I asked him to remain after the others had gone and I could see him looking for a chance to escape. His eyes glanced to the door and to the windows as if he would break away. I fastened the door and put the key in my pocket. He looked up at me defiantly and said, “Shan’t I go out and get you a stick?” I talked gently to him of God, and the rude boy melted and the tears ran down his cheeks. Then I read to him from the Bible and I prayed with him until I knew my prayer was answered. We went home together hand in hand. When at home he amazed his mother by asking for the Bible and going apart with it to read and pray. The dear boy became transformed. A short time later he joined the Congregational Church and grew to be an honorable and upright man.

 

Another gem on page 31:

Mrs. Eddy once told of moving to North Groton, New Hampshire, in 1855 when she was Mrs. Patterson: “It was a beautiful spot, and among other good people there was one saintly man who was known as Father Merrill. I went to this good man and asked him if we could not on the Sabbath day hold a prayer meeting in the schoolhouse. He said, ‘Oh no, there would be no one attend. The people don’t care for such things and it would do no good.’ He yielded to my entreaties, and the following Sunday at three o’clock was appointed for our prayer meeting. The day dawned fair and beautiful, and three o’clock found Father Merrill and myself at the little school ready for the service. Congregation or no congregation we were resolved upon our service and we two held our service of prayer and praise. Fervent indeed were the offerings laid upon God’s altar that beautiful Sabbath afternoon. A service was announced for the following Sunday at the same time and place, and when the hour arrived there were three others present. The following Sunday there came together a good congregation and before the month was out the schoolhouse could not hold all who sought admittance. We opened the windows that those without might share the service.”


This reminds me of the ten Boom sisters (Corrie and Betsy) getting a prayer group going in a Nazi concentration camp. See Corrie ten Boom’s The Hiding Place.

Joyce Voysey


Sunday, 1 March 2026

A letter about accomplishment

I never fail to be touched by accounts of the life of Mary Baker Eddy. 

The Foreword to Twelve Years with Mary Baker Eddy concludes with an excerpt from a letter by Mrs. Eddy to the author, Reverend Irving C. Tomlinson.

She wrote: "The little that I have accomplished has all be done through love, --self-forgetful, patient, unfaltering tenderness."

The letter now appears in Miscellany, page 247 under the heading "To a First Reader".

Julie Swannell   

Popular Posts